River Condition Assessment (RCA)

Parent Previous Next

River Condition Assessment (RCA)


The RCA page estimates the condition of a river reach using the River Condition Assessment method (Gurnell et al., 2020), the method used to score river condition in the Statutory Biodiversity Metric for Biodiversity Net Gain (BNG). The RCA was designed for Modular River Physical (MoRPh) survey data. The RHS Toolbox applies the same indicators, river typology and scoring thresholds to River Habitat Survey (RHS) data, so a condition class can be derived for any RHS site already in your database.

Important. Results on this page are RHS-based estimates of the RCA. They follow the published RCA rules as closely as RHS data allow, but they are not a MoRPh survey. Check the current Statutory Biodiversity Metric User Guide for the survey methods accepted for a BNG submission. How each indicator is derived from RHS data is described in Appendix 5.

What the page produces

Before you start

The RCA page uses data entered or calculated elsewhere in the Toolbox. For the best results, complete these first:

  1. RHS survey data, including the 10 spot-checks and the sweep-up. The indicators cannot be calculated without spot-check data.
  2. Map Data tab. Extract map data for the site to obtain channel sinuosity, slope and the semi-natural (predicted) substrate. These are used to pre-fill the desk-study and bed-material indicators.
  3. Quality control. The overdeepened-channel record checked at the quality-control step is used to adjust the Final Condition Class.
  4. Indices. The width/depth ratio and the semi-natural substrate index calculated with the RHS indices are re-used here when available.

Any edits made on the RHS survey form are saved automatically before the indicators are calculated.

Using the RCA page

Work through the page from top to bottom. Each step depends on the one before it.


Step 1 – Desk-study indicators (A1–A5)

Indicator

Description

How it is filled

A1

Braiding index

Set to 1 (single thread) if left blank

A2

Sinuosity

From the Map Data sinuosity; if missing, estimated from the surveyed length and the straight-line distance between spot-check 1 and the end of the site

A3

Anabranching index

Set to 1 if left blank

A4

Level of confinement

Set to U (unconfined) if left blank

A5

Valley gradient

Estimated from the channel slope (Map Data) and the sinuosity

When you open the page, blank desk-study fields are filled automatically from these RHS proxies. Values you have typed yourself are never overwritten, so if you carry out a proper desk study (for example from maps or aerial imagery) enter your own values and they will be used instead.

To calculate A2 or A5 from your own measurements:

Tip. The assumed values for A1, A3 and A4 suit single-thread, unconfined rivers. Change them for braided, anabranching or confined reaches, as they affect the river type.


Step 2 – Bed-material indicators (A6–A8)

Indicator

Description

A6

Bedrock reach (yes/no)

A7

Coarsest natural bed material recorded

A8

Average (dominant) bed material size

A6 and A7 come from the substrate recorded in the spot-checks and the sweep-up. A8 is taken from the semi-natural substrate prediction (Map Data) when available, otherwise from the substrates recorded at the spot-checks. Using the predicted semi-natural substrate avoids a modified bed (for example silted or reinforced) changing the river type.

These fields are filled when the page opens if they are blank. Click Calculate A6–A8 to recalculate them: this overwrites any values already entered. A note saying where A8 came from is added to the river-type comments. If there are no map data for the site, a message reminds you to use the Map Data tab first.


Step 3 – River type

Click Preliminary type to run the RCA typology decision tree. It needs A1, A2, A3, A5, A6, A7 and A8; a message lists them if any are missing.

The preliminary type is shown in its own box. The River type used for scoring is selected in the drop-down list:

Note. The decision tree has no branch for sites where the coarsest recorded substrate (A7) is finer than the predicted dominant substrate (A8), or where no substrate was recorded. In that case the Toolbox derives the type with A7 set equal to A8. A7 itself is not changed, and a note is added to the river-type comments. The RCA guide also recommends this substitution where coarse bed material is of artificial origin.

The river types and their names are those of the RCA guide. Large rivers and navigable rivers/canals have their own types and thresholds.


Step 4 – Additional site information

A few RCA indicators need information that RHS does not record. Answer these before calculating the indicators. All are optional: the calculation still runs without them, but the related indicators may be under- or over-estimated.

Field

Used for

What to enter

Leaning / J-shaped trees

B2, C2

Whether leaning trees, J-shaped trees, both or neither are present

Tributary junctions

D3, D4

Number of tributary junctions within the site

Dominant bed reinforcement type

E9

Material of the main bed reinforcement, if any

Bridge piers in the bed

E10

Number of bridge piers standing in the river bed

Surveyed length

Count rescaling

Length surveyed, if not the standard 500 m

Rescale counts (tick box)

Count rescaling

Leave ticked to adjust counts of features to the shorter MoRPh survey length; untick to use the raw RHS counts


Step 5 – Calculate the condition indicators

Click Calculate indicators. The Toolbox calculates the 32 indicators, then the Preliminary Condition Score and, if a river type has been selected, the Final Condition Class.

Positive indicators (features of good condition) score from 0 to 4. Negative indicators (pressures and modifications) score from 0 to −4.

Zone

Positive indicators (0 to 4)

Negative indicators (0 to −4)

Bank top

B1 vegetation structure · B2 tree feature richness · B3 water-related features

B4 non-native invasive plant (NNIPS) cover · B5 managed ground cover

Bank face

C1 vegetation structure · C2 tree feature richness · C3 natural bank profile extent · C4 natural bank profile richness · C5 natural bank material richness · C6 bare bank extent

C7 artificial bank features · C8 bank reinforcement extent · C9 bank reinforcement severity · C10 NNIPS cover

Channel margin

D1 vegetation extent · D2 vegetation richness · D3 margin feature extent · D4 margin feature richness

D5 artificial features

Channel bed

E1 vegetation type richness · E2 tree feature richness · E3 hydraulic feature richness · E4 natural feature extent · E5 natural feature richness · E6 material richness

E7 siltation · E8 reinforcement extent · E9 reinforcement severity · E10 artificial features · E11 NNIPS extent · E12 filamentous algae extent

You can overwrite any indicator score, for example where you have better local information. If you do, note why in the comments and click Calculate indicators again only if you want the scores to be recalculated from the RHS data (your changes will then be replaced).

Note. E7 (siltation) uses A8, so complete Step 2 before calculating the indicators.


Step 6 – Read the results

Preliminary Condition Score. The average of the positive indicators plus the average of the negative indicators. It can only be calculated when all 32 indicators have a value; otherwise a message lists those missing.

Final Condition Class. The Preliminary Condition Score compared with the class thresholds for the selected river type:

Value

Final Condition Class

3

Good

2.5

Fairly Good

2

Moderate

1.5

Fairly Poor

1

Poor


Overdeepening. Where the RHS records the channel as overdeepened, the class may be lowered, following the RCA guide:

If you decide to change the class yourself, edit the Final Condition Class and record your reasons in the comments.

Width/depth ratio is reported as a supporting check. A ratio below 4 is flagged as a likely overdeepened channel.

Comments. Each calculation adds a dated entry giving the Preliminary Condition Score, the Final Condition Class, the width/depth ratio, any overdeepening adjustment and notes on how specific indicators were derived (for example where sweep-up data filled a gap in the spot-checks). Earlier entries are kept below, so the comments box is also a history of the calculations for the site.


Interpreting the results


Messages you may see

Message

What to do

No spot-check data found for this site

Enter the spot-check data on the RHS survey form, then recalculate.

Data for indicator A1, A2, A3, A5, A6, A7 and A8 are required to run the decision tree

Complete Steps 1 and 2, or enter the missing values yourself.

You need to input valley and river lengths first

Enter both lengths before clicking Calculate A2.

River length / valley length cannot be equal to 0

Check the lengths entered.

Valley altitude difference cannot be less or equal to 0

The upstream altitude must be higher than the downstream altitude.

There are no map data information and predictions for your site

Use the Map Data tab to extract sinuosity and the semi-natural substrate prediction.

The Preliminary Condition Score needs all 32 indicators

Enter or recalculate the indicators listed in the message.

Select the river type to derive the Final Condition Class

Select a type in the River type drop-down list (Step 3), then recalculate.

No condition class thresholds available for this river type

Select one of the RCA river types.


See also


References

Gurnell, A.M., England, J., Shuker, L. and Wharton, G. (2020). Assessing river condition: a multiscale approach designed for operational application in the context of biodiversity net gain. River Research and Applications, 36, 1559–1578. https://doi.org/10.1002/rra.3673

Gurnell, A.M., England, J., Shuker, L. and Wharton, G. (January 2024 update). A guide to assessing river condition (link).

Natural England / Defra. The Statutory Biodiversity Metric – User Guide (current edition).